You must log in or # to comment.
Calling it “AI Art” gives it too much credence. They are generated images. Nothing more.
Depends entirely on your definition of art.
To me, art is “playing with your senses”. The way a painting plays with your vision. Music plays with your hearing. Food plays with your taste. …
And in that sense, a generated image is art. Especially if it evokes emotions like hate for being AI generated.
Regardless of definition, art requires an intention. You cannot find art in the wild, it has to be created.
There’s intention in a prompt. Death of the Author makes the case for valuing interpretation over intention anyway.
It’s a pointless waste of time to make the distinction.
It’s not.
Words matter. For example, calling an LLM “AI” has incorrectly shaped people’s perception of its abilities. This is a core aspect of marketing for this reason, and the choice to call it “AI” was specifically to take advantage of how much word choice matters in shaping perception.
Video games have been calling computer opponents AI for years and no one bothered to complain that those aren’t actually intelligent.
No one expects the AI in warcraft 3 to be able to solve all the world’s problems, so I don’t know why this suddenly became different.
I don’t understand your examples, nobody is saying these AI generated images aren’t AI
Yeah yeah. The definition of AI has now fundamentally changed. Notice that I never said an LLM is not a form or subset of AI at all. The term “AI” has a much broader scope than an LLM and because of that people think it can do more than it is capable. An LLM cannot reason—it just predicts the next most likely word to follow with some additional weights as a loose guideline.
Posting only a link to a wikipedia page is obnoxious. You’re not even bothering to explain how you think it’s relevant. In this case that would be particularly important since the “AI effect” you linked has nothing to do with what I said.
Are you too lazy to even explain, are incapable of explaining, or are you just regurgitating whatever you can find in an attempt to overwhelm with low-effort “arguments”? (This is rhetorical. Please just go away, since you’re clearly only here with bad faith.)
The definition of AI has now fundamentally changed.
“The AI effect” refers to a phenomenon where either the definition of AI or the concept of intelligence is adjusted to exclude capabilities that AI systems have mastered.
The really frightening part is that she really is out there somewhere and almost nobody knows where and she could show up at any time. Then out of nowhere…GOOP right on your face.
#Gwinning
That was beautiful
Terrifying
Edit: Beware the Goopacapra!
Our only hope is… Shia Labeouf.
Out of the corner of your eye, you spot him…
Shia LeBeouf
He’s following you about thirty feet back
He gets down on all fours and breaks into a sprint
He’s gaining on you!Shia LaBeouf
Lookout Ricky it’s the Samsquanch!
