• Kroxx@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    arrow-down
    10
    ·
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    Nah it’s easy just rewire the whole government in your free time, that’s what I don’t understand about these people. They have all these great ideas about organizing and starting this and changing that. The suggestions they give are just not realistic in our society currently, but they act like you’re the problem for voting.

    Y’all understand that your little suggestion of starting a whole ass movement with the only resource of “unified voters” in one of the most diverse countries in the world will take a ton of time right ?

    I’ll even play let’s say we:

    If you care how you vote, you should be getting organized with likeminded people to create a voting block that makes demands

    Do you think this can be organized 1 before the election, 2 before the election with enough time to actually change things in it, 3 by people working full time jobs and probably living paycheck to paycheck 4 while being fought back against the entire time by media oligarchy? No it isn’t realistic

    What is realistic is trying to save the country from a centralization of powers into the executive branch (project '25) that will almost surely lead into fascism, which will then in turn fuck the rest of the world even worse.

    • TheOubliette@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      9
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      3 months ago

      Nah it’s easy just rewire the whole government in your free time, that’s what I don’t understand about these people. They have all these great ideas about organizing and starting this and changing that. The suggestions they give are just not realistic in our society currently, but they act like you’re the problem for voting.

      As an organizer in my free time it’s hardly unrealistic to suggest other people do the same. These are also well-demonstrated strategies, whereas individualistic lesser evil voting is not. You just disempower yourself.

      And as you can see, this false logic also leads liberals to begin defending the lesser evils. Right now, they are defending genocide. My hope is that a few of them may break free of their propaganda and become true allies of people around the world and their own neighborhoods.

      Y’all understand that your little suggestion of starting a whole ass movement with the only resource of “unified voters” in one of the most diverse countries in the world will take a ton of time right ?

      God forbid political power take work and time. Better to be ineffectual and rhetorically entrench the sociopathic status quo, eh?

      Do you think this can be organized 1 before the election, 2 before the election with enough time to actually change things in it

      No. It requires shedding the political myopia that ensures your complacency. But you should begin building it now, and it is okay for its birth to be fitful. Begin having conversations now to see who would be interested. Join a left org that may be interested in this. Stop defending genocide.

      3 by people working full time jobs and probably living paycheck to paycheck

      Yes. This is how it has been for hundreds of years. People with less time and means did far more than this. You just have to actually believe that politics is important.

      How much time do you spend on social media, for example? Why not spend that time organizing meetings?

      4 while being fought back against the entire time by media oligarchy?

      Our enemies include that but are even larger and more powerful.

      No it isn’t realistic

      Far more has been done before. You gave been taught complacency. And to defend the status quo.

      What is realistic is trying to save the country from a centralization of powers into the executive branch (project '25) that will almost surely lead into fascism, which will then in turn fuck the rest of the world even worse.

      You aren’t saving anything. Your strategy makes you a complacent individual that simply allows the same system chugging along into depravity, like open support for genocide. You aren’t even organized. How on earty could you ever take credit for anything? Pure fairy tales.

      Do you even live in a swing state?

      • Kroxx@lemm.ee
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        4
        arrow-down
        4
        ·
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        As an organizer in my free time it’s hardly unrealistic to suggest other people do the same.

        Im sure as someone who does it everyday you do think that

        God forbid political power take work and time. Better to be ineffectual and rhetorically entrench the sociopathic status quo, eh

        This is the largest point I’m trying to make the time and effort it will take cannot be completed before the election. I mean you even agreed:

        Do you think this can be organized 1 before the election, 2 before the election with enough time to actually change things in it

        Your response was No.

        Yes. This is how it has been for hundreds of years. People with less time and means did far more than this

        Do you think every American agrees and will just jump on board?

        And to defend the status quo.

        No defending it I hate it but stop acting like it can change before the election, it is not enough time which is my point, not a defense.

        How much time do you spend on social media, for example? Why not spend that time organizing meetings?

        Couple hours after work, 10 mins before work, and while shitting. Drive times alone wouldn’t be meet with this time.

        How on earty could you ever take credit for anything?

        Don’t know what I took credit for but sure

        Do you even live in a swing state?

        Do you even live in America?

        • TheOubliette@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          4
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          3 months ago

          Im sure as someone who does it everyday you do think that

          I don’t do it every day. But I do it often enough to be reliable and have good capacity.

          But it’s not just me nor has it ever been. People from all nations have done this. People in far worse conditions. It is necessary and, historically, feasible so long as you can break false consciousness.

          This is the largest point I’m trying to make the time and effort it will take cannot be completed before the election. I mean you even agreed

          To begin building the necessary project you have to reject the political election myopia that our masters impose on us. Politics does not restart every 2-4 years. Only long-term engagement and the development and wielding of leverage will ever liberate us.

          Do you think every American agrees and will just jump on board?

          No, but why do they need to? Our task requires work and time. You keep acting like this makes it impossible. I suggest that this is a learned helplessness, of internalizing the false idea that there is no alternative. In fact, there has always been an alternative and others have blazed trails.

          No defending it I hate it but stop acting like it can change before the election, it is not enough time which is my point, not a defense.

          It is already a defense in that it is a form of apologetics for the genocidal status quo. It defends and entrenches the idea that your job, politically, is to decide who to cheerlead with a vote. It normalizes accepting and tolerating the genocide of Gaza, as even that us not enough for you to take sufficient pause. You are lost in propaganda, but you can free yourself through education.

          Couple hours after work, 10 mins before work, and while shitting. Drive times alone wouldn’t be meet with this time.

          A common dedicated organizing commitment is 1-2 meetings per week (often online) and around one action per month. Though there are often opportunities to do what works around anyone’s schedule.

          Don’t know what I took credit for but sure

          There is a tendency in bourgeois electoralism to dramatically exaggerate the impact of a given activity. Usually, but not always, voting. The purpose is to make the target audience feel like what they were told to do matters, was worthwhile, and to keep them doing it. This is what I am referring to by credit - of an exaggerated assignment of value to the activity I was responding to.

          Do you even live in America?

          Why would that matter? My question to you does matter: if you don’t live in a swing state your presidential vote is as worthless as it gets.

          What would your point be if I were or were not American? Please don’t be xenophobic.

    • Soulg@sh.itjust.works
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      4
      ·
      3 months ago

      It’s absolutely wild seeing unhinged ranting posts get upvoted while posts like yours are getting downvotes. What the hell kind of community did I stumble into